For Whom the Bell Tolls…Not for Me or Thee!
But it sure looks as if it may toll for Michael Ignatieff.
With the Liberal leader in as certain, albeit slower, and more painful, a freefall as his predecessor, Stephane Dion, brave Michael is surely going into a sure season of discontent. He’ll be spiking the eggnog with a little something stronger if this trend holds, even for another quarter. The Liberals have no loyalty to anyone except the suits in their backroom, who either write the cheques or scour Bay Street for yet another willing dupe. They will want to cannibalize their leader in no time flat.
There were four byelections held across the country last night: One in New Westminister, that was taken, as I expected, by the NDP; two in Quebec, that were split between the Tories in rural Quebec, that they had no business winning, and the Bloc coasting to victory in Hochelaga; and finally in Nova Scotia, where the Tories collected a seat they have rarely lost since Confederation.
It was a very successful night for the Prime Minister and his crew, one which they MUST build upon or they can forget a majority in the next election. The gains in Quebec have to bee seen as significant and they have to be cultivated. They won in polls they have never factored in previously and kept to simple messaging, nothing fancy.
Above all, they did two things in Quebec that they have NEVER previously done (had they, he’d be in his second majority). Firstly, the Quebec win was accomplished with the harvesting of a good, reasonable, MODERATE, local candidate, and the campaign infrastructure was run like a national campaign (significant, too, was the crossover between Team Charest provincially and Team Harper–previously an unholy alliance…now firmly in detente). Usually, the Tories ran Quebec campaigns based strictly on previous results, and with a few changes, rolled out similar, if not identical campaigns, time after time. Well, not last night. Their GOTV (get out the vote) was superb and they had huge swaths of the riding identified well before the middle of the campaign. Secondly, it didn’t hurt that Stephen Harper has softened his messaging approach: No more bare knuckles, in fact, he kept his fingers were they defined him best–on a keyboard. If you think that the Prime Minster’s kinder, gentler approach hasn’t changed Tory fortunes in Quebec, then you haven’t seen the booming poll numbers for the Conservatives around the Island (of Montreal). All those suburban ridings can be in play if he keeps his infamous penchant for blunt force trauma in check. The Tories don’t need the elites and navel-gazers in Montreal.
In New Westminister, Fin Donnelly won with a 15 pt spread. He is popular locally and is the brother of SFU swim coach Liam Donnelly, who had his otherwise happy life infested by perennial nutbar, psycho-blogger, wannabe pundit and infernal pretender Rachel Marsden. Donnelly did well to play off the current, high popularity of the NDP in this province. Thanks to (madman) Gordon Campbell’s HST, which Donnelly made the number one issue, the NDP picked the seat, which I fully expected, contrary to local Tory predictions. New West is still very blue collar and the sentiment against the provincial govt is so high, that they were able to tar the Tories, too. People were angry and it showed.
As for Nova Scotia, the maths is simple enough: Other than the Bill Casey foolishness of the previous some years, the Tories own this seat. But they made great gains and I gather the expansion of the Tory base in the Maritimes helps, as does a renewed relationship between the Prime Minster and Nlfd Premier Danny Williams.
Three final observations: The Liberals shrank in key areas of every one of the four by-election ridings. This is very bad news for the party that (in the depths of delusion) considers itself Canada’s govt-in-waiting. Particularly in New Westminister, where they had super-organizer Greg Wilson and former candidate Mary Pynenburg, front and center–their vote was dismal. Surprising, for that riding and considering Wilson’s expertise (Pynenburg, on the other hand, has rarely seen an election she hasn’t helped sink)… In Quebec, as I have stated many times before, the infrastructure after the Denis Coderre fracas of last month, confirmed my suspicions that Ignatieff’s Rosedale mafia are destroying the party, piece by piece in La Belle Provence.
And to be sure, the Bloc are not resonating and while they have pockets of stalwart support, generational change and false predictions of peril without a national identity’ have sunk them. They must count on the battle axe brigade of Parizeau and Bouchard to spread the old canard about confederation–to the few that will know listen.
Finally: The NDP are really not a national party, just a protest destination. Outside of B.C., Winnipeg and northern Ontario, they don’t even matter. Layton can rage against the dying of the light (with apologies to Dylan Thomas) all he wants to, it’s over for socialism in this country. The NDP can never claim anything more than that they are the pace for left-wing Liberals and disaffected Greens to park their votes.
The times they are a changing…thankfully.
You can read various analyses here, here and here.
And you can certainly see how Mr. Ignatieff has been having a very bad couple of days, considering how the by-election results were bad enough. Read it here.

Thanks for the link.
As for your contention of pending NDP irrelevency – well, an increased vote count and seat count over the last several elections, first breakthroughs in Quebec and first provincial government win east of Ontario in Nova Scotia – all just in the last couple of years.
The facts are at variance with your thesis.
[Translate]
Hi Cliff:
My pleasure to link up with you. You’re coverage of that nutbar Marsden is superb. But I’m afraid it might be you that has the NDP narrative backwards. If Mulcair hadn’t come from the Liberal wing in Quebec, no chance of taking Outremont. Where else have the NDP made substantial gains outside B.C.? Nowhere. In B.C. they have been riding anti-Campbell sentiment from 2001 and can’t capitalize. Any gain they make, comes crashing down because this country wasn’t built on all hand-outs, all the time. The NDP didn’t do well at all after last election, notwithstanding Layton’s moderately good performance through the campaign. But in Quebec, in particular, the have seen bumps in support, that quickly fall to earth. Any up in the polls can also be attributed to Layton attempt to cut a deal separatist vermin. So, I’m not wrong at all. The calculus is simple: The NDP are irrelevant and NOT a national party, since they can only register cyclical advances and retreats in limited areas of this land.
I like your website. Cheers!
[Translate]
I had to read this twice to make sure you weren’t referring to the Campbell excuse for government with this line:
“…… this country wasn’t built on all hand-outs, all the time. ”
Sounds just like Lord Gord, handouts to his cronies, railroads, public utilities, taxpayer $ to the likes of Dobell, Kinsella, Hahn etc. etc.
I guess the divide between left and right is a matter of income distribution – the left thinks the have nots should have some and the right thinks the have mores don’t have enough until they have it ALL!
[Translate]
Hi Kooter: Not quite sure I agree with all your statement, but you raise some very valid points, as per usual. Particularly about Lord Gord
[Translate]
“The NDP are really not a national party, just a protest destination. Outside of B.C., Winnipeg and northern Ontario, they don’t even matter. ”
=======
I know the Tory pony express is slow but the New Democrats are now the government in Nova Scotia, and have been the government of Manitoba for some time. They are the official opposition in Saskatchewan and here.
They have MP’s from Nfld, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Quebec, Ontario, Manitoba , Alberta and here. They are the effective opposition in Ottawa thanks to Iffy and his principle-less band.
Wheras the Canadian Tories once had a sense of history and of community they have left those values to the social democrats and have commenced worshipping at the altar of market ideology. George Grant was right.
The social democratic Nordic model is increasingly seen as a postive alternative to the failed consumer capitalist model exemplified by the USA.
[Translate]
Ron: In case it hasn’t occurred to you, if it wasn’t for the personal popularity of Dexter in NS and Doer in Manitoba your NDP would be circumnavigating the political toilet rim. All the others you quote as huge successes, have been won or lost over time as protest votes settled. Outside of the areas I mentioned, where the NDP have deep roots, the rest of your “examples” are meaningless.
Nice spin though, “they have MPs in Quebec…Alberta”. Sure, how many? Remove Mulcair, as an exception since he also had personal appeal as a provincial Grit, then what? Yes, again, to aLberta, that stronghold of NDP support. Be serious. George Grant? Did I ask if you were serious?
The NDP are “Real” opposition? You knew you were into a possible election eight months ago, since the Grits were making so much noise, and you feckless leader, who tried to cut a shameful deal with separatist bastards, supported the Tories to save his own bacon, since you didn’t even have half of your ridings with nominated candidates and barely $2M liquid cash in the account.
Yeah, that sounds like a great deal of widespread support alright. LMAO!
Please if you’re going to come here and challenge me to a gunfight, don’t bring a butter knife,
Because I don’t miss.
[Translate]
Well it appears that the Liberals want us to forget that They are The Culture Of Entitlement. We haven’t. This is the very revelation that sent them packing. They figure that enough water has passed under the bridge, that we have forgotten their abuse of Power [think Adscam].
Did I mention, we haven’t?
Cheers
[Translate]
Yes Gary, that’s precisely what they want. They want us to forget. They are aching for us to forget. Beyond incredible. Thx for stopping by. I appreciate your thoughts.
[Translate]